context: Beijing's 'strong supply, weak demand' diagnosis points to an economy operating below potential. Seen through the output gap, this suggests room for stronger demand without immediate overheating. Yet cutting excess capacity threatens employment, while new industries may generate more output than jobs. Ahead of the Central Economic Work Conference, this tension complicates the stimulus debate.
Closing the PRC's negative output gap faces constraints on both supply and demand, argues Guan Tao 管涛 Huafu Securities chief economist. Weak prices and underemployment suggest the economy remains below potential. International Monetary Fund staff estimated the output gap at -1 percent in 2025.
The options for closing the gap are limited, notes Guan
- cutting excess capacity risks job losses
- traditional firms crowding into emerging sectors may generate fresh overcapacity
- government investment faces local fiscal stress, debt resolution pressures and a shortage of viable projects
- weak demand and expected returns constrain private investment
- consumption subsidies provide temporary support
- but they cannot sustainably lift spending without stronger long-term income expectations
- capital-intensive emerging industries generate relatively few jobs
- this limits their direct contribution to household income and consumption
Traditional industries still account for around 80 percent of manufacturing value added and employment, Guan notes. Upgrading these sectors therefore remains essential to balancing productivity gains with employment.
He calls for stronger countercyclical policies, faster 'six networks' investment and a concrete urban-rural household income growth plan, backed by improved income distribution and social security.